‘Social Security is broke beyond belief’: Economist says the US retirement safety net is full of holes — how to protect yourself and secure your golden years
Story by Vawn Himmelsbach, Moneywise, 5/20/24
Many Americans aren’t saving enough for retirement — and they’re relying on Social Security benefits to get by in retirement. But that may not be a sound strategy.
“Social Security is broke beyond belief,” Laurence Kotlikoff told The Brink, Boston University’s research news website. “Its unfunded liability is $65.9 trillion — twice the size of official government debt.”
The “retirement planning evangelist” and professor of economics at Boston University says that paying for all projected benefits through time requires “an immediate and permanent hike” in the employer-employee FICA tax from 12.4% to 17%. The Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) tax is a combined employer-employee federal payroll tax.
Without it, Social Security payments are on track to be reduced as soon as 2034.
Even if Social Security benefits are still paid out in full, many Americans face complicated hurdles in the system.
“For far too many of America’s seniors with any but the simplest situations, negotiating the complexities and outright scams of the Social Security system on their own is nigh impossible,” Kotlikoff told The Brink. “Kafka could not have designed a more complex set of provisions with hidden catch-22s that can haunt you — in the form of clawbacks — decades after you start collecting benefits.”
Given these issues, it might be a good idea to reduce your dependence on Social Security and take charge of your own retirement. One way to do this is by maxing out your contributions to tax-advantaged retirement accounts, such as your 401(k).
Beware the bait and switch
The Brink article lists lists five tips for retirement savings, including plan within your means, maximize benefit matches, save in addition to your retirement program, use planning tools, and wait longer to collect Social Security benefits.
“Even after Social Security contributions, and after 401(k) contributions, they should probably be saving another 15% of their take-home pay, which is very tough,” Kotlikoff says. He noted that perhaps 40% of those eligible for a 401(k) don’t take advantage. “Most people are saving nothing.”
He added that everyone who expects to “sustain their living standard through retirement” needs to do economics-based financial planning because “conventional planning is an elaborate bait and switch designed to sell you investment products that are highly expensive and overly risky.”
He describes the economics-based approach as determining a sustainable living standard based on your resources, and adjusting your spending as your circumstances change, so you don’t outlive your savings.
Given that Social Security is, in Kotlikoff’s words, “broke beyond belief,” it’s worth exploring other options. It could be a good idea to consult a financial planner to determine which options are best for you.