Title
(Ref: John Bouvier, A Law Dictionary Adapted to the Constitution and Laws of the United States of America and the Several States of the American Union, Childs & Peterson, c1856.)
TITLE estates. A title is defined by Lord Coke to be the means whereby the owner of lands hath the just possession of his property. Co. Lit. 345; 2 Bl. Com. 195. Vide 1 Ohio Rep. 349. This is the definition of title to lands only.
There are several stages or degrees
requisite to form a complete title to lands and tenements. 1st. The lowest and most
imperfect degree of title is the mere possession, or actual occupation of the estate,
without any apparent right to hold or continue such possession; this happens when one man
disseises another. 2 Bl. Com. 195. 2dly. The next step to a good and perfect title is the
right of possession, which may reside in one man, while the actual possession is not in
himself, but in another. This right of possession is of two sorts; an apparent right of
possession, which may be defeated by proving a better; and an actual right of possession,
which will stand the test against all opponents. Idem. 196. 3dly. The mere right of
property, the jus proprietatis without either possession or the right of possession. Id.
197.
A title is either good,
marketable, doubtful, or bad.
A good title is that which
entitles a man by right to a property or estate, and to the lawful possession of the same.
A marketable title is one which a court
of equity considers to be so clear that it will enforce its acceptance by a purchaser. The
ordinary acceptation of the term marketable title, would convey but a very imperfect
notion of its legal and technical import.
To common apprehension, unfettered by
the technical and conventional distinction of lawyers, all titles being either good or
bad, the former would be considered marketable, the latter non-marketable. But this is not
the way they are regarded in courts of equity, the distinction taken there being not
between a title which is absolutely good or absolutely bad, but between a title, which the
court considers to be so clear that it will enforce its acceptance by a purchaser, and one
which the court will not go so far as to declare a bad title, but only that it is subject
to so much doubt that a purchaser ought not to be compelled to accept it. 1 Jac. &
Walk. R. 568. In short, whatever may be the private opinion of the court, as to the
goodness of the title yet if there be a reasonable doubt either as to a matter of law or
fact involved in it, a purchaser will not be compelled to complete his purchase; and such
a title, though it may be perfectly secure and unimpeachable as a holding title is said,
in the current language of the day, to be unmarketable. Atkins on Tit.2.
The doctrine of marketable titles
is purely equitable and of modern origin. Id. 26. At law every title not bad is
marketable. 6 Taunt. R. 263; 5 Taunt. R. 625; S. C. 1 Marsh., R. 258. See Dalzell v.
Crawford, 2 Penn. Law Journ. 17.
A doubtful title is one which the
court does not consider to be so clear that it will enforce its acceptance by a purchaser,
nor so defective as to declare it a bad title, but only subject to so much doubt that a
purchaser ought not to be compelled to accept it. 1 Jac. & Walk. R. 568; 9 Cowen, R.
344; vide Title, Marketable.
At common law, doubtful, titles
are unknown; there every title must be either good or bad. Atkins on Tit. 17. See Dalzell
v. Crawford, 2 Penn. Law Journ. 17.
A bad title is one which conveys
no property to a purchaser of an estate.
Title to real estate is acquired
by two methods, namely, by descent and by purchase. (See these words.)
Title to personal property may
accrue in three different ways. By original acquisition. 2. By transfer, by act of law. 3.
By transfer, by, act of the parties.
13-Sec. 1. Title by original
acquisition is acquired, 1st. By occupancy. This mode of acquiring title has become almost
extinct in civilized governments, and it is permitted to exist only in those few special
cases, in which it may be consistent with the public good. First. Goods taken by capture
in war were, by the common law, adjudged to belong to the captor, but now goods taken from
enemies in time of war, vest primarily in the sovereign, and they belong to the individual
captors only to the extent and under such regulations, as positive laws may prescribe.
Finch's Law, 28, 178 Bro. tit. Property, pl. 18, 38; 1 Wilson, 211; 2 Kent, Com. 290, 95.
Secondly. Another instance of acquisition by occupancy, which still exists under certain
limitations, is that of goods casually lost by the owner, and unreclaimed, or designedly
abandoned by him; and in both these cases they belong to the fortunate finder. 1 Bl. Com.
296. See Derilict.
14-2d. Title by original
acquisition is acquired by accession. See Accession.
15.-3d. It is acquired by
intellectual labor. It consists of literary property as the construction of maps and
charts, the writing of books and papers. The benefits arising from such labor are secured
to the owner. 1. By patent rights for inventions. See Patents. 2. By copyrights. See
Copyrights.
16.-Sec. 2. The title to personal
property is acquired and lost by transfer, by act of law, in various ways. 1. By
forfeiture. 2. By succession. 3. By marriage. 4. By judgment. 5. By insolvency. 6. By
intestacy.
17.-Sec. 3. Title is also
acquired and lost by transfer by the act of the party. 1. By gift. 2. By contract or sale.
In general, possession
constitutes the criterion of title of personal property, because no other means exist by
which a knowledge of the fact to whom it belongs can be attained. A seller of a chattel is
not, therefore, required to show the origin of his title, nor, in general, is a purchaser,
without notice of the claim of the owner, compellable to make restitution; but, it seems,
that a purchaser from a tenant for life of personal chattels, will not be secure against
the claims of those entitled in remainder. Cowp. 432; 1 Bro. C. C. 274; 2 T. R. 376; 3
Atk. 44; 3 V. & B. 16.
To the rule that possession is the
criterion of title of property may be mentioned the case of ships, the title of which can
be ascertained by the register. 15 Ves. 60; 17 Ves. 251; 8 Price, R. 256, 277.
To convey a title the seller must
himself have a title to the property which is the subject of the transfer. But to this
general rule there are exceptions. 1. The lawful coin of the United States will pass the
property along with the possession. 2. A negotiable instrument endorsed in blank is
transferable by any person holding it, so as by its delivery to give a good title "to
any person honestly acquiring it." 3 B. & C. 47; 3 Burr. 1516; 5 T. R. 683; 7
Bing. 284; 7 Taunt. 265, 278; 13 East, 509; Bouv. Inst. Index, h.t.